Please select your home edition
Edition
YY.com app (top)

Bluewater Cruising: Cutter Rig versus Solent Rig - Part 2

by Kerri Robson, Upffront 20 Nov 2018 09:00 UTC
Diagram showing the Cutter Rig versus the Solent Rig © Calanach Finlayson, Upffront.com

In a previous blog, Upffront evaluated the pros and cons of a cutter rig as a popular bluewater cruising set up. Now, it's the turn of the solent rig.

Like the cutter rig, the solent rig also utilises two headsails; the two different sized genoas sit close together, the second just behind the main forestay, unlike those on the cutter which sit relatively far apart.

So, how does a solent rig compare to a cutter rig?

Unlike the cutter rig, it is not intended for both headsails on a solent rig to be flown at the same time. That said, it is possible to use twin headsails (which help to steady the boat) to sail dead-downwind, with one sail poled out to starboard and the other to port. This is one of the major advantages of the solent rig. However, the downside of poled out twin headsails is that quick, emergency, changes of direction are problematic.

The solent rig does provide great scope for flexible headsail choices. You may have 2-3 sails in your existing wardrobe which could be recut by your sailmaker to give you more upwind / reaching flexibility across a range of wind conditions. You could explore different combinations of larger 150% genoas and smaller 100% jibs and, once setup, you have lots of options available to you, without the need for every going onto the foredeck.

However, despite its simplicity and ease of use, the solent rig is not as performance orientated as the cutter rig: when sailing close to the wind, the furled sail can interrupt the airflow over the sail that is being flown, reducing efficiency.

Without additional aft support, the forestay tension is shared between the two forestays, meaning the luff of both sails can fall away excessively upwind.In addition, there is no need for any additional backstays as the in-line stays are attached close to the masthead, which makes the solent rig a budget friendly option. The solent rig is thus – in theory – an easier retrofit: it requires just a solent stay attachment below the existing forestay, and a new halyard sheave. It is also common to use a 3:1 purchase system under the drum of the solent stay and make it a semi-removable system, to facilitate easier tacking of the main genoa, in light, upwind conditions.

Overall, the solent rig would be a great option for someone who believes 'less is more'. With two well-made headsails, in theory the rig should allow a sailor to go anywhere without ever venturing onto the foredeck... so, for short-handed, globe-trotting on a budget - and with plenty of time available - this could be an excellent option!

However, as you know, here at Upffront we are passionate about providing performance products and advice. If pressed to choose, we are a fan of the cutter rig together with the use of code zeros and asymmetric spinnakers, which we believe offers a complete, modern, bluewater cruising solution. It is often worth spending a little extra time and expense, to begin with, to get the best solution.

If you would like to talk to someone about your rig setup or a retrofit project, please feel free to contact upffront.com using our genoa reefing enquiry form!

Related Articles

Nick Black Talks Main Halyard Locks
Final discussion in the series on lock systems for yachts The final in our series on lock systems for sailing yachts, Andy Rice talks to Nick Black of Rigging Projects about mainsail locks. Reef locks have taken off in a big way in recent years, mostly because clew loads have become higher and higher, Posted on 14 Jan
Introduction to Winches
With recent innovative features and performance improvements Although the fundamental mechanics of winches have not really changed over the years, there are some innovative features and performance improvements which have appeared in the industry in more recent years. Posted on 11 Jan
Top-down and Bottom-up Furling Units
Differences and options broken down by upffront.com What are the key differences between bottom-up and top-down furling units and do I need a dedicated unit for each type of furling? The primary difference is that a top-down drum has the addition of a free floating tack swivel mounted on the furling drum. Posted on 28 Dec 2018
Nick Black and Andy Rice on Furling Halyard Locks
Bringing costs down to a more reasonable level The new generation of swivelling locks combine a tripless locking system with a high-performance bearing system. An enormous amount of R&D has gone into the development of these fittings, which is why for many people they are also too expensive. Posted on 21 Dec 2018
Structural Furling Forestays
An increasingly popular, lightweight alternative Continuous line furlers, together with a torsional cable, is an alternative furling system for the main structural forestay. This is an increasingly popular, lightweight choice for both racing and cruising sailors. Posted on 17 Dec 2018
Furling Systems: Options and Accessories
Several other furling considerations need to be taken into account When purchasing a furling system, there are several other considerations that need to be taken into account to ensure you have a fully operational furling system. Some are basic/essentials and others are optional extras. Posted on 12 Dec 2018
Is it worth paying for better running rigging?
The cost versus benefit trade-off for a 25ft boat What is the cost versus benefit trade-off for running rigging options on a 25 ft sailing boat? We take a look at three running rigging specs and investigate whether the increase in cost is justified by the performance benefits. Posted on 7 Dec 2018
Top-down versus Bottom-up Furling Cable Specs
What to look out for Have you got any idea what's the difference in design between a top-down or bottom-up torsional cable? Find out what makes a good torsional cable and the important differences between the two applications. Posted on 3 Dec 2018
Brand New Bamar Furling
Two well-engineered product ranges available now If you're a regular visitor to Upffront.com, you will have noticed two new impressive additions to our website: the Bamar RLG EVO Gennaker Furling and the Bamar GFM Manual Foresail Furling systems. Posted on 28 Nov 2018
Make Waves with nke Marine Electronics
Innovative systems for racing or cruising It's the age of information, and global technological advancements have revolutionised our lives and industries alike. As with many others, the sailing industry has benefitted from the introduction of marine electronics that make it easier. Posted on 23 Nov 2018
YY.com app (top)